The Devine Ideal Weight Formula Came From a Drug Dosing Paper — Here's What Actual Health Outcomes Research Shows Instead
The Devine ideal weight formula appeared in a 1974 drug dosing paper — it was never derived from health outcome research. Here's where each major formula came from (insurance actuarial tables, drug pharmacokinetics, military studies), what mortality outcome data actually shows about "healthy" weight (lowest mortality at BMI 22-25 but the curve is flat 20-27), and why the obesity paradox in clinical populations complicates the "lower is healthier" framing.